Japanese athletes under fire after Asian Games scandal
When four members of Japanâ s national basketball team were sent home from the Asian Games last month for patronizing prostitutes, the resulting scandal capped almost a yearâs worth of bad publicity for sports in Japan. Over this time weâve had allegations of âpower harassmentâ raised against the Japan Wrestling Federation, the premeditated dangerous tackle by a member of the Nihon University American football team, accusations of misuse of funds by the Japan Amateur Boxing Federation, and charges of physical abuse and harassment in gymnastics.
As media critic Minako Saito wrote in her Sept. 5 Tokyo Shimbun column, these stories are like something out of a comic book where good and evil are clearly delineated. Real life is never so Manichean, but the media play it out that way, and sometimes itâs difficult to get a sense of whatâs really going on. In a Sept. 1 Tokyo Shimbun column about online media, Junichiro Nakagawa claimed that TV has led the charge against the miscreants in these scanda ls because they work in amateur sports, which âdonât have a deep relationship with television,â or, at least, not as deep as professional baseball does. TV reporters can cover the scandals any way they want without worrying about repercussions. Itâs easy to make Japan Amateur Boxing Federation President Akira Yamane into a villain because of his gangster-like appearance and demeanor. Nakagawa repeatedly uses the term ânÅkin,â an abbreviation of the phrase ânÅ miso ga kinniku,â which means âthe brain is a muscle,â an insult commonly directed at people in sports, especially administrators who were once athletes themselves. The feeling is that they run things based on entrenched tradition without ever questioning that tradition, so when a scandal erupts they appear clueless.
The basketball scandal is no different, though the focus on sex makes it more problematic for the mainstream media. The tabloid media has no problem at all, and while that gives them an advantage in terms of ethical guidelines â" they arenât expected to follow any â" it also highlights their culpability in sustaining the attitudes that give rise to such scandals.
The weekly Shinchoâs coverage of the basketball story was typical. Describing the news conference with the four disgraced athletes after their return from Jakarta as a âpublic execution,â the magazine revealed its stance, which is that the matter was blown out of proportion by the mainstream press, who kept demanding the players apologize to the nation in humiliating fashion. These young menâs lives, and not just their careers, have been destroyed.
âThey were treated like the worst criminals,â said the writer, who proceeded to explain their crime from the standpoint of someone who might have done the same thing if he had been in their situation â" although he would have been smarter about it. According to Shincho, the scandal was a confluence of three factors: too much beer af ter a preliminary victory in the tournament, a team rule obligating the players to wear their uniforms when there were out in public and the playersâ naivete. When they left the drinking establishment after midnight, the players were approached by prostitutes and followed them to a hotel. An Asahi Shimbun photographer was hanging around and saw the initial exchange. The photographer even took pictures.
Shincho reinforces its position with quotes from sources whose take on the scandal is not sports-related. A Japanese reporter who lives in Jakarta explains how the neighborhood where the players drank has become more amenable to prostitution in recent years. The editor of a magazine about the Asian sex trade compared Indonesian prostitutes to those from other countries (âmore polite than Thais or Filipinos,â âmore service for less moneyâ). A sociologist lamented âsocietyâs demandâ that athletes be saintlier than âregular people.â And media maven Dave Spector commented about the ridiculousness of holding athletes to higher moral standards when âall they want to do is play sports.â
Shincho questioned the Asahi Shimbunâs decision to report the playersâ late night rendezvous, implying that the newspaper, acting out of a smug sense of journalistic professionalism, not only ruined these playersâ lives but brought attention to this area of Jakarta and, at least temporarily, scared away business. The reporter added that South Korea was probably happy about the scandal.
Shincho wasnât alone. Twitter and other social media were filled with complaints about the Asahi Shimbun, whom some accused of purposely wrecking Japanâs basketball chances at the Asian Games, although most of these critics hate the media organization to begin with.
The newspaper declined to comment on the record for Shincho, although if they had they could have pointed out that athletes participating in international competitions can be disqualifi ed for buying prostitutes. As reporter Yuko Shimazawa asked in an Aug. 22 article in Business Insider Japan, Didnât these four players know about the campaigns, supported by numerous world athletic bodies, to prevent trafficking at international sports events?
Probably not, she assumed. The U.S. State Department issued a report in June in which Japan was ranked among the worst tier one countries in the world in terms of prostitution and trafficking and has no effective penalties in place. (Governments in tier one countries fully comply with the Trafficking Victims Protection Actâs minimum standards.) This lack of accountability is an outcome of Japanâs poor comprehension of human rights, Shimazawa says.
Bolstering this attitude are the twin beliefs that nothing can be done about menâs desire for sex and that male athletes need sex to relieve the tension generated by competition. The mainstream press crucifies players for revealing that Japanese athletes canât t ranscend these impulses, while the tabloid press dismisses the scandal as merely a boys-will-be-boys thing. Both implicitly blame the prostitutes, because male athletes donât know any better. Thatâs as good an illustration of âmuscles for brainsâ as youâre going to get.
LATEST NATIONAL STORIES
- LDP election rivals Abe and Ishiba campaign on disaster resilience during visit to Kyoto
- Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and former Defense Minister Shigeru Ishiba focused on the importance of building resilience to disasters as they campaigned in Kyoto on Saturday, dueling on the last we...
- Swine fever virus in Gifu found to be variant new to Japan
- The type of swine fever virus recently detected at a pig farm in the city of Gifu had not been found before in Japan, the National Agriculture and Food Research Organization said. The var...
- News outlets fret over the nation's docile democracy
- "Nazism." "Fascism." "1984." "Kamikaze." Strong words , suggestive language. It's going mainstream. An Asahi Shimbun editorial on July 29 drew comparisons between the administration of Prime Mini...